Chicago's Pizza Geist

Welcome to the Best Pizza in Town!

Discover our family-friendly atmosphere where every bite tells a story. Enjoy our signature deep-dish, traditional or then pizza, fresh-baked breadsticks, and a selection of pasta dishes. We’re more than just a meal; we’re a place to gather with your loved ones every day of the week.

Location Details

Restaurant Hours

Dine-in, Carry Out and Delivery
Monday 11 a.m. – 8 p.m.
Tuesday 12:30 p.m. – 8 p.m.
Wednesday 11 a.m. – 9 p.m.
Thursday 11 a.m. – 9 p.m.
Friday 11 a.m. – 9 p.m.
Saturday 11 a.m. – 9 p.m.
Sunday 11 a.m. – 9p.m.

Explore Geist's Charm

Geist is a vibrant community with a rich history, known for its beautiful lakes and engaging local events. Families love gathering here for picnics and fun activities, making it a perfect spot for dining and recreation.

Why Choose Us?

We’re more than just a restaurant; we offer a gathering place for friends and families. With our signature deep-dish pizza and freshly baked breadsticks, every meal is a chance to create unforgettable memories with loved ones in a welcoming environment.

Join Our Community

We take pride in being a local favorite and strive to stay connected with our community through events and special offers. Come visit us and experience the warmth and camaraderie that Geist has to offer—where every meal feels like home.

What Our Customers Say

"Craving a good pepperoni breadstick and these were it! Customer service was great. I ordered the pepperoni breadsticks with nacho cheese and marinara sauce and a root beer. Everything was fresh and delicious."
S.H.
"Love the lunch buffet. Great salad selection and delicious pizza. Plus, kids eat for super cheap!"
K.D.
Perfect for schools, teams, churches, groups, bands and clubs!

Chicago's Pizza Fundraisers

Chicago’s Pizza fundraisers in Geist are an incredibly simple and effective way for your group, organization, or team to raise money while enjoying delicious pizza! Chicago’s offers not just one but two great ways to partner with us and make your fundraising efforts a success. You can join us in the restaurant for a fun-filled Dine to Donate evening, where a portion of the proceeds will go directly to your cause, or you can choose to sell our popular pizza vouchers, which can be redeemed in the store for our mouth-watering pizzas! Our vouchers offer flexibility and value, making it easy for your supporters to participate. If you would like more detailed information or have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact a manager at our location, and we would absolutely love to assist you in getting started on this exciting fundraising journey!

Chicago's Pizza Geist Fundraiser Options

Dine to Donate

Pizza Vouchers

PizzaParty

This Restaurant's Owners

Our McCordsville location opened in 2008, and was later purchased in April of 2019 by current owners Jon Grunden and Sean Booher. Jon and Sean have over 25 years of experience between them, and have worked together for the last seven. In the summer 2023, they moved to their new location on Oaklandon Road in Geist.

Jon, Sean and their wonderful restaurant staff have done a tremendous job of focusing on the basics. Their mission and focus is to make quality pizzas and to ensure their customers’ happiness. 

“The most important thing to Jon is to really make our customers feel more like family,” Sean shared. “We want to know our regulars’ names and strive to make that extra effort to make everyone feel welcome. We truly appreciate the support the community has shown us in our time here.”

“Chicago’s Pizza changed my life for the better in so many ways,” Jon added. “I chose to become an owner so that I could create those same opportunities for others. Helping others achieve their goals is the ultimate motivator.”

Jon Grunden McCordsville FINALcropped 1366x1127 1
Jon Grunden
SeanBooher Plainfield McCordsville 1T8P9967 r
Sean Booher